Finkelstein, a contemptuous jew pretending to be at odds with other jews

[checkitb4uwreckit]

A brilliant critique of Norman Finkelstein posted by DICARLO on Incogman.net:

   

To clear up any misconceptions about Finkelstein, there's nothing special about Finkelstein. He's just another contemptuous jew pretending to be at odds with other jews. He talks about the holohoax all the time but has come under fire from his fellow jews only because he criticizes them for their commercialization of the "holocaust". However, make no mistake. He is a proponent of the official jew narration of what happened in the camps during WW2.

    According to this jew, only jews can be scholars on the events of the holocaust, so therefore, in the opinion of this arrogant jew, no non-jew is credentialed to speak about it. A few years back, he refused to attend the Holocaust conference in Iran because he objected to others speaking there who do not believe the official jew line, and have other views, such as David Duke and other knowledgeable investigators of this hoax.

    In 14 different countries, any reference to events other than those sanctioned by jews will result in legal prosecution which could result in years in prison and heavy fines. So, this jew, Finkelstein, refuses to speak in the one place where others could speak freely? This jew, as with all jews, only wants one side of the debate aired. He doesn't want the holocaust to be discussed from any point of view other than the jews point of view. The holocaust is an out and out fraud. Finkelstein is no friend or ally of non-jews.

[checkitb4uwreckit]

A lot of left-wing Muslims adore this guy because he defends Palestinians. Fact is he is a shill and a phony. I seen a video of him on Youtube giving a speech where someone asks him about Israeli involvement in 911 and he began to ridicule any suggestion that anyone other than the fictional Al Qaeda did it.

[Timothy_Fitzpatrick]

A lot of left-wing Muslims adore this guy because he defends Palestinians. Fact is he is a shill and a phony. I seen a video of him on Youtube giving a speech where someone asks him about Israeli involvement in 911 and he began to ridicule any suggestion that anyone other than the fictional Al Qaeda did it.

Perhaps, but his book is doing more good than harm.

[Michael K.]

I wouldn't be in such a hurry to judge him.  Nobody sees all angles, but Finklestein sees well enough what the problem with Jewry is.  The thing is, he also loves his own people, and why shouldn't he?  He is a human being with a mother who is a Jew.  I don't know what happened in the Nazi camps, but a lot of people died miserably there.  Why argue that the Nazis were somehow innocent of all wrongdoing?  That's as big of as mistake as believing the 'jew soap' story.  The truth is that, if only 100,000 people were killed in Nazi concentration camps so that Zionists could have a pretext to take over Jerusalem, then that was a 'holocaust'.

[checkitb4uwreckit]

I wouldn't be in such a hurry to judge him.  Nobody sees all angles, but Finklestein sees well enough what the problem with Jewry is.

No, Finkelstein chooses not to see such angles and snides great Holocaust revisionists like Arthur Butz and Zundel. Finkelstein is no Benjamin Freedman, not even close.

I don't know what happened in the Nazi camps, but a lot of people died miserably there.

And I blame those deaths on the British and American bombers for the most part. They bombed the hell out of German supply lines. Those people wouldn't have died had the Allies not done that -- the Germans were feeding everyone adequately in the camps up until the obliteration of their supply lines near the end of the war. The Allies were the most egregious war criminals of all time. And on top of that, those camps wouldn't have even been constructed, and thus nobody put in them, if France and Britain had not maliciously waged war on Germany in 1939, at the behest of their Jewish stringpullers.

Why argue that the Nazis were somehow innocent of all wrongdoing?  That's as big of as mistake as believing the 'jew soap' story.

Don't get the analogy. Nobody says they are innocent of all crimes (how is it possible to not commit crimes during a world war?), but they are innocent of most of the obscene crimes they have been cheaply accused of by the Jews and their lapdogs, who themselves were guilty of some of the worst crimes ever committed. The Nuremburg trials was an outrageous farce, that is to be sure.

http://www.cwporter.com/partone.htm

The truth is that, if only 100,000 people were killed in Nazi concentration camps so that Zionists could have a pretext to take over Jerusalem, then that was a 'holocaust'.

If that's so, then why aren't we calling the mass murder of millions in the Communist Gulags a "Holocaust"?? The Allied firebombing of Dresden is a real Holocaust (burnt offering). I would never accept the use of that term to characterize Jewish deaths in WW2 because just the word itself implies I have accepted the official Jewish narrative of what happened, which any person who's studied the evidence simply cannot do. And many, many more Gentiles were killed in and after WW2 than Jews. Jews suffered no more and perhaps even less than Gentile nationalities. Every country in WW2 had concentration camps and put people whose country of origin was on the opposing side in the war, in them.

Sounds like you got some real sympathies for Jews though. Are you forgetting that the Bolshevic mass-murder apparatus was Jewish-run? Who mourns for their countless victims? You'll never see a Jew shed a tear, not even a crocodile tear, for a Gentile death.

[Michael K.]

MSMD,

I have some sympathy for the Jews as human beings.  However, I agree with you that whatever happened in to Jews in Nazi concentration camps pales beside the systematic destruction of huge swathes of Europeans at the hands of the USSR, and the Allies.  It is hyped up disgracefully, this Jewish Holocaust.  I mean, 50 million people died in WWII, and maybe 10 million more were murdered after the war for political reasons, the vast majority of them non-combatants.  I just don't think Finklestein is my mortal enemy or anything.  He is just a man with all the flaws that a man has.  At least he is being courageous in the face of all sorts of peer pressure from other Jews.  I think you could pick on more loathsome ones.

[checkitb4uwreckit]

MSMD,
However, I agree with you that whatever happened in to Jews in Nazi concentration camps pales beside the systematic destruction of huge swathes of Europeans at the hands of the USSR, and the Allies.

I'd say. The Nazi camps were 5 star hotels compared to the Soviet Gulags, and even the Allied camps.

I just don't think Finklestein is my mortal enemy or anything.

Didn't say he was an enemy. But a contemptuous, arrogant, gatekeeper.

He is just a man with all the flaws that a man has.  At least he is being courageous in the face of all sorts of peer pressure from other Jews.  I think you could pick on more loathsome ones.

I do pick on more loathesome ones, all the time.

[Timothy_Fitzpatrick]

Wasn't there a swimming pool at Auschwitz?

[SPECTEC]

[youtube:10sszm9x]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SubGJrEowJo[/youtube]10sszm9x]

Is he lying about his family? After watching David Cole's film, I find it hard to believe his family was "exterminated" at Auschwitz...I would say he might be gatekeeping.

[checkitb4uwreckit]

[youtube:ga6nacey]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SubGJrEowJo[/youtube]ga6nacey]

Is he lying about his family? After watching David Cole's film, I find it hard to believe his family was "exterminated" at Auschwitz...I would say he might be gatekeeping.

Well he wouldn't exist if that were true.  I think he claims that everyone previous to his mother and father were "exterminated". He provides no evidence that they died of anything other than typhus/starvation or were general casualties of the war. Do we see Germans running around claiming their entire families were "exterminated" by Jews, WHICH THEY WERE after the war in large numbers? No because Germans have self-respect and are not sympathy-seeking psychopaths. Plenty of people were exterminated by Jewish Communists and their servants, which we hear nothing about.

Someone should research his family history to see if he has any aunts, uncles, etc, which would prove he is lying about that.